Fishing Forum

Full Version: Bear River Bottoms Bonanza
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Cliffnotes Version: Went to some water, caught some fish, then the bugs ate me.

Reel Story: Stopped along the VV hwy for a gander at some water near the dump - Loads of minnows - getting bigger. I didn’t count them, but lots. Didn’t find any predators hunting them, as I’d expected (ok, hoped). Ah well.

Hit a spot along the bear river - near a bridge, somewhere in the Benson area. Didn’t bring the camera down with me- so don’t have a “photo essay”, sorry. Had caught my first crappie and hooked up some carp a few weeks back. THIS time I went targeting Crappie, and caught a carp as well - reverse story. Got to my ‘spot’ where an ‘arm’ of black backwater joins the river. Lots of eddies to play. Ironic that the black tea-stained water of the ‘arm’ is clearer than the muddy water of the churned up river (keep hearing the song in my head ‘Catfish are jumping, that paddle wheel pumping, blackwater …’ though I always tell myself it’s just carp jumping). Again LOADS of minnows - varying sizes. I think the minnows in the arm draw in biggers at the mouth. My assumption proved itself.


Started off under bobber with a tincy jig tipped with worm. Got some bobber bounces, and managed to time the hit, and - lo and behold - a decent crappie came to play. Kept working the eddies and hooked up some more takers. But missed plenty of bobs, and burned through worms in the process. Finally decided to ditch the bobber, and just jig it. GOOD plan. Got hit after hit. Couple snags too, even had a snag that started moving sideways - and then started running line. Had the drag set low (lefty loosie) for the lil’ crappie, and had a fight on my hands. Once I tightened down, and reached for the net - guess what?! Wrong - it wasn’t a carp - it was my first Bear River Smallmouth Bass! Wohoo. Not a monster, but not a baby either - and the fight vs. the crappie/panfish was distinct. Soon followed another smallie, but smaller - but again a fun tug. So - two species, one day. Schwing!

Next pleasant surprise was not a beast, but a bluegill. Went back to grow up a bit. Followed by another surprise - a green sunfish. Another bitty bite, but distinct - longer length, horizontal stripes, no vertical - no photo to prove it, but pretty sure - it was what it was. 4 species, 1 hour. Bingo!

Next up to bat was another big tug - ooh, another bass - but this sucker is taking SERIOUS runs, it’s determined. Ran and ran and ran. Ok - big scales, carp on. Good to have the mud-boots on so I could step into the river and net it up. Catfish bait! Not a monster by carp standards, but on a small jig and light tackle, fun tugs all the same.
My second rod had been soaking a worm, and I’m sure if I’d given it attention could have hooked up something, the end of my worm kept getting chewed, but I was pretty focused on the jiggin’.

As the moon came up, the bite dropped off. (ok, NOW I’m sorry I didn’t bring the camera down - that was a COOL view!) I realized I had slowed my presentation, and that worked for the little guys. But I was getting tired of the dozens of bitty bites that still kept me entertained (can‘t keep count). So I aimed out of the arm to deeper water, and picked up the pace. Light bulb! These guys don’t want dine it, they want fast food takeout! Quicker retrieve, bumps and jumps - and the big bite was back. Bigger fish, faster action. Goes back to why I needed to ditch the bobber in the first place. These guys wanna CHASE! My stinger kept getting heavier, and as the light faded, and the bugs decided it was time for the big bite - figured I’d best call it a night.
Spent a few hours by the river, and filled a mixed bag (5 species, three new for the Bear for me). Got home and spend some time filleting. Fish Tacos for lunch today!

Of note: Sometimes you have to throw the whole tackle box to find what they’ll bite - this time I used one little jig, and it produced and produced. I had hits even when the crawler tipping was chewed off. A bit of glow helped after dark too. A tungsten jeweled jig - very very small. It’s an ice-fishing jig, but who has to wait for the snows to fly? Had plenty of others to choose from - but if it ain’t broke… well, by the end if the night - it may have been badly bent.
Nice work and nice post man! I like the "Reel" story best. I thought you were full of it when you told me there were all those species in the BR. Nicely done!
Nice job on the Crappie and SMB. Always fun catching all those species.

Reading the novel, I kept waiting to hear about a broken knot or log wrap-around! Way to go, man.
[signature]
Had a lotta lotta grabs that got loose, so I won't claim any percentages, but I will say I was pleased not to lose that one little lure. Was ready to go wading if I had to, but managed to release all my snagups by moving around and jiggling.

Didn't have any knot failures, but a couple birdsnest tangles popped off the reel, so I did have a few "reties" to contend with.

Figured I'd blabbed on enough, so didn't go into ALL the details. Had I brought the camera to the water, probably would have had less catching to talk about anywho.

Had some 'bass tacos' for lunch. As usual, the daughter was big on bass (or most any fish). Quick marinade in milk, white wine, creole spice. Crunchy - egg wash, panko dipped - light fry. Yum!

Jdawg- I've 'fished' cutler/bear so many times without catching anything, yet heard so many stories of so many species. I was pretty amazed myself to find so many different fish in one spot (on a single jig at that). I'm starting to be a believer. Had my second rod took off with a walleye hookeup - wouldn't have been in hog heaven!!!
Great job on the river! I loved the novel, please keep the informational posts up. I love the taste of bass too, but I beer batter them. It is always a treat to have a variety for the fryer!

When I played on the little bear river we used blue "ice flies" in April below the dam of Porcupine (it wasn't ice fishable then, missed it by that much). Anywho we got a few followers but no takers. Still it encouraged me to try my ice gear any time of the year!
[signature]
Nice haul ona mix bag !!!However your Crappies are no chunks nor slabbos..[Wink]The real slabs sleep @ Pineview up here in these Northern parts & Willards got some toads too!!! Did u or did you happen to see any one catch any Eyes up there???
[signature]
I know they get biggerer, but for me - if it's larger than my hand, I'll call it a slab. Plenty were little chippers for sure. Had twice as many that went back in the drink. The top of the stack was 11", so not too bad.

Now toads are bass, right? Slabs are crappie? (and little lambs eat ivy). Those bass weren't toads, but the weren't bitty basslings either. And they shore do fight and put on a show. Leapers! So I'm thinking it might not always be carp I see flopping!
You've iced a few of those slabbos from the view yourself if'n I recollect. Found a few under ice there, but nothing to write home about. Ben landed a chunky one. Haven't met a Willard crappie yet, though I'm sure I've sat on top of a few schools as they taunted me. Maybe I need to try some fast-food-presentations!

And TDT - I ramble on, I know it. Some folks are bothered by long posts, far as I know there's no policy about length (unless your falsifying your pics![blush]), as I see if - folks don't have to read what they don't want.
For me - it's more a matter of my own journaling. Maybe next year I'll remember what worked when.
Don't get the wrong impression. I love novel type posts. The more info on a persons day the better IMO! It helps me know what may work when and if I ever head that way.

A comedian was talking about fonts conveying emotions. He said "dude I wrote that in Good Time's Roman, Not sarcastica"! In this case it was the "Good Times Roman" bro. [Smile]

Hey at least this time they noticed ya and added some positive comments! [Wink]

Next year you ought to try for the Willard Slabs. They are easy to find at the North Marina in the spring. Just look for 15 bank tanglers and 4 boats with 3 to 4 guys on them apiece all throwing their stuff in a 5 by 10 foot section up against the shore.

Combat fishing at it's finest!
Nice job Yote I haven't seen that many at one sitting from the Bear in several years glad to see you had some fun. Later J
[signature]
Thanks to you bud. Down the road from your pa's. You probably know the exact spot (so maybe there's a reason I left the camera in the car - but that moonrise really was wicked). I landed probably twice more than I kept - the little buggers were plenty frisky, but they need time to mature!

Still haven't bumped into your old friend, or any of the Walleye! Guess I gotta work downriver more.

Sarcastica. I'm going to have to use that one at work!
I managed to miss the "spring staging" at Willard. I did take a couple ventures, but haven't had much luck on them there. Need to try my "magic jig" next time. Sometimes smaller is better.

PS: Bear Bottoms is a totally different place that where I was at, FWIW. Just seemed like a catchy title.
Were you in the spot you caught your first crappie out there or on the other end of things? I've been catching Panfish on the dry fly lately it's a total blast but they have been really little and it's a short bite only good for about an hour each day. But I did get my daughter to catch some on the dry fly so that was the best part of it watching her get excited trying to hook those quick little buggers.
Well Mr Walleye is just growing up for you and you'll meet soon. That's really good if you caught a bluegill out there I've fished it a lot over the years and never caught one on a pole. Now green sunfish is a different story. There are a lot of them they are sort like the mud cats and carp. Keep fishing the same areas and you'll get your large mouth and walleye but your perch you may have to go upstream. Rural legend has it that they used to catch them where summit creek empties into the bear. I've never caught one but heard stories of some being caught in that area. Good luck on your quest. Later J
[signature]
[fishon]
Nice Catch coyote!!! Sorry I didn't read your novel!!! Maybe only the first line...then I saw the rest and figured I didn't have time ;-)
[signature]