Fishing Forum

Full Version: i wanna catch a toad
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
I am from logan and i want to catch a large fish... perhaps a catfish or tiggggermusk how can i do this any help ???
[signature]
for the last few years i have been on this website and have found that there is really only one thing that you need in order to catch a big muskie and that is TIME. Fishing and researching.
A tiger musky is a fish of a thousand casts.
I have spent 3 summers averaging 20 hours a week looking for a big tiger and still haven't found one.

if you want to catch a biggun then find the cheapest way to hit pineview and hit it. [cool]
[signature]
[quote FishHunterSmoot]for the last few years i have been on this website and have found that there is really only one thing that you need in order to catch a big muskie and that is TIME. Fishing and researching.
A tiger musky is a fish of a thousand casts.
I have spent 3 summers averaging 20 hours a week looking for a big tiger and still haven't found one.

if you want to catch a biggun then find the cheapest way to hit pineview and hit it. [cool][/quote]

...bolded is a fact hands down and for a fish 45" plus fish with lots of time on the water learning. Proper equipment is vital and a MUST. Including someone really serious about catching a TOAD TM will do homework meaning become a student of the required equipment and learning all one can about the fish. HOURS on the water along employing them 3Ps = Passion, Persistence, Patience. If you want to catch a TOAD fish you gotta put the time in is about alls I'll say.
[signature]
I'm a Logan-ite (cache valley anyway), and agree with the notions set forth. I'm almost embarrassed to say my biggest landed T-Musky was on a deadstick. (right lure, right time).

Newton is the closest CV target for Musky. There are some seasoned pigs in there! Pineview is your other target. As suggested - make sure you've done your homework on handling, release of this resource. They are precious! (and they aren't dumb!)

I'll be targetting spring bassm, musky up there. Be glad to hookup if you're heading that way.
[quote FishHunterSmoot]
A tiger musky is a fish of a thousand casts.
[/quote]

At 39 inches I sure did not catch the biggest Tiger Muskie on the block...but I got 2 in less than 8 casts. And for the record it was no accident...I pulled up on shore and said out loud I want a Tiger Muskie and I got em.

Too bad TM fisherman are so tight lipped and unwilling to help....you are gonna have to get out the binocs when you see em out on the water....or pay them $500 for a half day and $1,000 for a full day...no refunds of course.

Hope someone comes out of the closet and helps you out.

[fishin] BRING IT ON GUYS and GALS[fishin]
[signature]
Throw big, flashy baits. Or throw big baits that put off a lot of vibration.

By big I'm talking nothing smaller than 5".

If you cast and cast, the muskies will come.
[signature]
My experience with tiger musky has been different than what a lot of people will tell you...I have caught big fish out of Newton, Pineview, as well as others without spending loads of time...

...personally, I think the trick is to find something new. In both Pineview and Newton, fishing pressure was relatively high for the toothy buggers and catching fish was exactly like people described until I found that one lure...my first big Musky came on a pink pixie, and it was no fluke. I had cast every big crankbait, rattletrap, and musky lure I had when finally I became desperate. So, I tied on the relatively small pink salmon spoon and started casting. Within minutes I had landed my first musky on my first outing to Pineview...before I had left I had landed seven more small fish. The following day I returned and fish a couple hours more. My results with the pixie were the same--I caught numerous fish and ended my day with a pretty nice fish--45 inches. That was about 10 years ago.

On Newton my experience was similar...fishermen were strewn across the lake fishing for virtually every kind of fish under the sun including Musky. It was July and I was determined to land at least one. Again, I threw every lure in my box including an array of pixies that I now carry with me whenever I musky fish...nothing was working and the fishing was driving me nuts because I was seeing fish on the surface fairly regularly. About an hour before dark my floating rapala tangled itself and spun across the surface as I reeled it back in...to my surprise, a musky hit the lure as it spun in not how the lure was designed to work. It was my first kind of action all day...so, I intentionally connected one the lures hooks into the swivel portion of the steal leader and began casting. Again, within minutes I had a second take and my first fish...at dark, I landed my second fish--a 43 inch musky that hit the tangled lure about 5 feet from my tube (I almost always fish for musky from a float tube...a lot of fun).

On my favorite Utah musky reservoir, I now always take my usual spinning gear and tackle but also always bring my fly rod and fly assortment along as well...it seems that at this particular lake that fish are relatively easy to catch early in the season but as fishing pressure mounts, the fishing gets tougher and tougher with my usual tackle. But, not with the fly rod...the exact opposite happens.

If you want to catch a big fish, yeah....you just might have to spend some time. But, I strongly suggest that you look for things that are a bit out of the ordinary and see if you can trigger a response...in my experience that difference has made all the difference. I now spend usually 2or 3 days a year fishing for tiger musky...not very many. But, in those 2or 3 days, I have always been fortunate enough to catch some musky and now have caught a handful of fish over 20 pounds. These big ones are perhaps not the monsters that lurk, but I think they would probably make you Smile!

And, FWIW, I definitely think big musky are easier to catch and require less effort and time than big lake trout....
[signature]
i guess i just got lucky fishing newton and PV. i just looked for a decent structure.... trees/sticks.stunpms in the water, easy access to deeper water, water temp, etc and started fly fishing for them. my first ever attempt at them on the fly rod produced one on a big top water fly on my third cast. granted nothing trophy worthy but still. my one and only lvery limited piece of advice is to keep your eyes peeled for likely holding structure, good luck
[signature]
Ya want big fish, use big baits period, no matter the species.
[signature]
[quote FishHunterSmoot]for the last few years i have been on this website and have found that there is really only one thing that you need in order to catch a big muskie and that is TIME. Fishing and researching.
A tiger musky is a fish of a thousand casts.
I have spent 3 summers averaging 20 hours a week looking for a big tiger and still haven't found one.

if you want to catch a biggun then find the cheapest way to hit pineview and hit it. [cool][/quote]

Seems like pretty good advice haha..

Why does this fish seem so hard to catch?
[signature]
wow what a response!!! thank you all very much its very interesting to find out there are many methods to catching these toads!!! Havnt caught one this year yet! I will have to apply some of these new tips and methods this year will post if successful
[signature]
I could be wrong on some of this so if anyone knows the truth please feel free to correct me.

There are several reasons why they are hard to catch. for one they are extremely territorial. They will only be one musky every so often. Also a tiger musky is steral so when they are put into a lake there are just that many. thats it. no more. slowly they will die off from dumb fisherman and territorial reasons. And they are really smart to
[signature]
no doubt musks can be difficult to catch
[signature]
Good vibrations. I think part of why the twisted crank would work is it flails and splashes. Other topwaters that have prop blades can help with that. Flash, or dark shadows - changes in direction.
Musky are a fish that might follow a lure for a long time w/o striking.
You see different results from folks - big lures, little lures. There's the match-the-hatch notion, but with such seasoned fish - something new and novel might make the difference.

I've caught them on a home-made spinner blades - perch pattern, but simple beads and hammered gold.
[inline "Perch Pattern Blades.jpg"]
The Bagley Belly button was a killer - again - perch pattern. Been trying to tye up some similar - green, yellow, orange. Little glitter or flash.
[inline BagleyBellyButton.jpg]

Or you can go big - flashy big puffy spinners - lots of marabooo. Or something with a paddle tail, or curly tail to move a lot of water.
[inline PMG08_BigBaitsA.jpg]

But - as K2 suggested - be prepared - you must be able to remove the hooks and revive and free a musky properly and safely. They can be dangerous (and kinda scary!) and the big baits, big hooks can be a hazard.
Don't plan on using a little wooden trout landing net for a Musky.
[inline TigerTeeth.JPG]