Fishing Forum
ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake - Printable Version

+- Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Utah Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=386)
+--- Forum: Utah Fishing General (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=58)
+--- Thread: ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake (/showthread.php?tid=1105278)

ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake - Piscophilic - 10-11-2024

A friend of mine named Ricky approached me at a neighborhood gathering back in August. He asked if I had been fishing lately. With a Smile, I gave him my usual Sunday answer, “Well, not since yesterday.” He proceeded to tell me about David, a friend of his that was complaining at work.
 
Apparently, the guy really loves catfish. He had been hitting Utah Lake for over a month with no success. He even said, “I’m so desperate I’m thinking of trying to catch a carp!”

Well, I couldn’t rest knowing that a cat fisherman might have to stoop to chasing those things, so naturally I offered to help. “It gets really tough fishing for cats from the shore in late summer,” I said, “but if he wants to go out with me on the boat, we can find him a cat or two.”
It has taken almost 2 months and several failed attempts to get out together, but it is finally going to happen this weekend. Yesterday, I decided to go out after bait for the upcoming trip.

I hit the harbor about 8 P.M. and things were slow. Only one 5” YOY whitie in the first 20 or 30 minutes, so I moved to a new spot. Jon and I had tried that spot a week or so ago and got mostly 6–8-inch crappie, but I needed more bait so I tried it again, hoping for more whities in the mix.

I must have missed 10 fish before I finally hooked up. The hits seemed like crappie, but the fish don’t always know how the are supposed to hit. First hook up and guess what, a 6” crappie. Second one, an 8” crappie. Sometimes I sure wish they were legal for bait at UL!
Then something changed. I started casting more parallel to the shore and rattle, rattle, set…I got another whitie! The next hit came almost at my feet and was clearly stronger than anything so far…I love ultralight fishing. To my surprise, it was a perch about 10 inches long!
Wow, up to 3 species and that guy would provide several good chunks of bait!

The next half hour produced half a dozen more whities, including a couple of the larger 6–8-inch variety, 2 more crappie and a 6-inch perch. Perch don’t usually feed much at night, so I was grateful these hadn’t read the perch handbook.  I now had enough for Friday’s trip, but I was having fun. “I’ll just get a few for Saturday,” I rationalized in that twisted reasoning I use when I don’t want to quit.

Another half hour gave about the same results, another half dozen little whites and a couple 6-8-inch crappie. Then I had another heavy-ish fish hit. Another good perch, I hoped, but it was another surprise, a 6” bullhead. As I released it, I thought, “4 species and not a channel cat or a carp!”

I set a timer on my phone so I would stop rationalizing and be able to get some sleep before work on Friday. Just before the timer went off, I found another hard fighting little guy. Yet another surprise, a 6” green sunfish! I decided to call it a night, before I started rationalizing about how I could get a 6th species!


[Image: Sunnie-after-dark.jpg]


All in all, a surprisingly fun bait run with 5 species and enough whites and perch for the weekend outings!


[Image: IMG-3781.avif]

RE: ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake - Cowboypirate - 10-11-2024

It is sure fun to fish those locations where a mixed bag is possible. Congrats

RE: ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake - TubeDude - 10-11-2024

What?  No June sucker?  They make good bait.  At least they did in the old days before they became protected darlings.

RE: ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake - wiperhunter2 - 10-13-2024

Amazing, that perch seems to dwarf those other fish. Nice work or should I say fun. So how did your trip out there turn out on Sat? Congrats on the 5 species day, sure don't hear many of those.

RE: ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake - Dirt Bag - 10-14-2024

(10-13-2024, 07:22 PM)wiperhunter2 Wrote: Amazing, that perch seems to dwarf those other fish. Nice work or should I say fun. So how did your trip out there turn out on Sat? Congrats on the 5 species day, sure don't hear many of those.

That is a great evening of fishing.

RE: ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake - Piscophilic - 10-15-2024

(10-13-2024, 07:22 PM)wiperhunter2 Wrote: Amazing, that perch seems to dwarf those other fish. Nice work or should I say fun. So how did your trip out there turn out on Sat? Congrats on the 5 species day, sure don't hear many of those.

Friday with the first timers was good. They got 8 cats in 2.5 hours and all 3 got one at least 10 pounds. Saturday Jon and I did better with a PB for me at 33". I'll get the reports out soon.
(10-11-2024, 10:06 PM)TubeDude Wrote: What?  No June sucker?  They make good bait.  At least they did in the old days before they became protected darlings.

Nope, no junies. I have actually never seen a live one, only pictures. I must not hang out in the right places!
(10-11-2024, 08:34 PM)Cowboypirate Wrote: It is sure fun to fish those locations where a mixed bag is possible. Congrats

Thanks, it is fun when it comes together like that. The cats loved the bait as well Smile

RE: ABC 5-Species Evening at Utah Lake - wiperhunter2 - 10-16-2024

(10-15-2024, 02:53 AM)Piscophilic Wrote:
(10-13-2024, 07:22 PM)wiperhunter2 Wrote: Amazing, that perch seems to dwarf those other fish. Nice work or should I say fun. So how did your trip out there turn out on Sat? Congrats on the 5 species day, sure don't hear many of those.

Friday with the first timers was good. They got 8 cats in 2.5 hours and all 3 got one at least 10 pounds. Saturday Jon and I did better with a PB for me at 33". I'll get the reports out soon.

Nice, congrats on getting your PB cat. It's amazing how many 10 lb cats came from UL this year.