Fishing Forum
not 100% sure on species - Printable Version

+- Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Idaho Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=353)
+--- Forum: Idaho Fishing General (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=25)
+--- Thread: not 100% sure on species (/showthread.php?tid=411592)



not 100% sure on species - trophyboat - 04-29-2008

I was ice fishing up at ririe reservoir through the ice this year and caught this trout, to me it is a rainbow, but i have caught 100's of trout ( in utah) and have yet to catch one that looks like this, is this a common looking trout in idaho? any info is greatly appreciated. It was released, those kokanne are alot better eating.
[signature]


Re: [trophyboat] not 100% sure on species - duksnfish - 04-29-2008

Must have forgotten the pic? Or was it a ghost you caught [:p]
[signature]


Re: [trophyboat] not 100% sure on species - windriver - 04-29-2008

Now you have got my attention I want to see the fish especially since I fish Ririe a lot.

Windriver
[signature]


Re: [windriver] not 100% sure on species - packfish - 04-29-2008

Sure looks like a bow to me.
[signature]


Re: [trophyboat] not 100% sure on species - line_dangler - 04-29-2008

Hello Idaho anglers!

I am from Utah and came across this thread. For what it is worth, I will state my opinion as to the identification of the trout in the pictures.

I think this is either a rainbow or a rainbow-cutthroat hybrid. It is not too often that such colors are seen, but often enough. The coloration (pale, and a bit dark-yellow greenish) is probably due to the water environent where it was caught.
[signature]


Re: [trophyboat] not 100% sure on species - Everet14 - 04-30-2008

The fish is a finespotted cutthroat trout.
[signature]


Re: [trophyboat] not 100% sure on species - iliketofish - 04-30-2008

I agree with Everet 14. It's a finespot cutthroat as far as I can tell. It doesn't have white fin tips, or any spots on the head as far as I can see, and it definately has fine spots. That was a good call to release it though, it's always better to play on the safe side when you are not sure.
Happy fishing!
[signature]


Re: [trophyboat] not 100% sure on species - riverdog - 04-30-2008

I'd go with the snake river ( fine speckled ) cutt or a cuttbow hybrid.
[signature]


Re: [trophyboat] not 100% sure on species - windriver - 04-30-2008

Everett14 is correct. It is a fine spotted cutthroat. There are many just like it in Ririe. Most people do not target the trout in the winter. I like to target them because they give my kids lots of action while I am waiting for Kokes.

Windriver
[signature]