Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
What to do with those catfish!
#1
I got thinking.......I think the catfish sometimes get a bad rap in Utah (trout fishing state) by some people and I've heard several folks tell me that they think catfish taste muddy. Well, I'm going to show you one way (of many I use) to put those fish to good use.

Most folk just think to coat the fillets in corm meal and deep fry, but there are several other ways to prepare them to be delicious without busting out the frying pan.

Ever hear of "poor man's lobster"? I'm sure many in here have, but I've never really known anyone to make it from catfish....myself included. I usually use stripers, walleye, crappie, etc. Turns out that catfish make excellent "poor man's lobster" if you take a few extra minutes to get it properly ready.

First, get that fish on ice as soon as possible, or at least in a live well so that they don't start deteriorating. Bleed them if possible if you are going to ice them.

Next, once you are home or wherever you are going to prepare them, fillet and (this is the important part) trim the dark meat and even the yellow meat by the head off. This will go slightly slimey or oily when cooked and give off that "muddy" taste that some complain about.

Once all that prep work is done, boil about 6 cups of water with 3/4 cup of sugar, 1-2 TBSP salt, and about 1-2 tsp old bay seasoning. Once it is boiling, drop your fish in and turn the heat down to a slow boil or simmer (keeps the meat from flaking apart). Continue cooking for about 5 minutes or so for catfish, or about 2 minutes for other fish (catfish taste best cooked longer). When done, remove and drain on paper towels. Microwave some butter with a little garlic salt until just melted and use that to either pour over the fish or just dunk the pieces in the butter like you would with lobster or crab. My kids were convinced that they were eating some sort of crab or lobster when I made this the other day for them.

Anyway, I'm bored at work at the moment and thought this might be helpful to someone who is wondering what to do with that catfish they or their kids kept. Btw, grilling them is MY favorite way to cook them, but this is a close second!

Mike

P.S. I tried to post these pics inline, but I couldn't get it to work.
[signature]
Reply
#2
Hillbilly lobster!!!!!!!!!!!
[signature]
Reply
#3
Exactly![laugh].
Also, you wouldn't believe how good it makes fresh planter trout taste.
[signature]
Reply
#4
I've had that recipe with striper at Powell, but boiled in 7-Up instead of sugared water.

It was good, but anyone who thinks it tastes like lobster has never had lobster. Or, if you did, it was lobster from some Utah restaurant - frozen and nothing like fresh.
[signature]
Reply
#5
Exactly right. It doesn't taste just like lobster, but it gets close enough to that crabby, seafood taste that it works pretty well to hold me over until my next trip to Joe's crab shack. I really like it because it's really quick, easy, and no frying to stink up the house like a fry basket.

Who knows, if we fried lobster in corn meal maybe it would taste more like fried fish and we wouldn't dig it as much.[Wink

Mike
[signature]
Reply
#6
Hey Mike, thanks for that recipe. I have eaten Catfish cooked many ways, all my adult life. And because I spent a about 15 years in the south (North Carolina, Georgia, Florida) I have caught and cooked a good portion of Cats. There are even deep fried Catfish on most buffet menus in the south. Most folks I have talked to that say they don't like catfish, or say it is a "garbage" fish, have either never tried it, or have had poorly prepared cat.
I was actually surprised to find cats of good size here in north Utah. Having never been here before 1999, I always thought it would be too cold here to support Catfish. I was sure glad to learn how wrong I was, 'cause I really like catfish.
[signature]
"OCD = Obsessive Catfish Disorder "
    Or so it says on my license plate holder
                                 
Cool
Reply
#7
[#0000FF]I make "pseudo shrimp" out of several of the white fleshed species. Use the Knorr's "Caldo de camaron" (shrimp bouillon) to add flavor to the poaching liquid. Then mix a little more in with the garlic butter for dipping. Bet it would work on small cats as well. Especially the Willard cookies.

Here are a couple more recipes that can add some zing to your kitties.
[/#0000FF]
[signature]
Reply
#8
Thx, gmwahl! Maybe I can get my kids to try it this time instead of lecturing me on pcbs
[signature]
Reply
#9
Mike, Thanks for sharing your poor mans lobster recipe.

I eat fish at least once a week and loving it. I have cooked a variety of fish several different ways but always looking for something new. Years past I poached crappie that I thought was OK but your recipe tasted better. Cooked up some catfish tonight. I will have to include this to my likes list.

As you said, not the fishy smell of fried fish lingering through the house.

Thanks again
Richard J
[signature]
Reply
#10
Thanks for those recipes Pat , I'm gonna try the second one on Father's day.

There are so many ways to make a good catch into a good dish that I could almost give up red meat completely.......but then I'd have to quit hunting and that just ain't gonna happen! I love trying different recipes that I haven't tried before.

Mike
[signature]
Reply
#11
Glad you had a chance to try it and liked it! Another good way to use those fishies!

Mike
[signature]
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)