07-05-2010, 08:40 PM
I fish Tonys Grove around a dozen times every year although I haven't yet this year. There are a lot of small trout in the lake but the fishing pressure usually keeps them pretty weary. I've had my best success casting small spinners and using small dry flies early in the morning or late in the afternoon. Four pound test leaders will dramatically up your chances when fishing gets tough. I've never used bait for them there. Around the little inlet seems to do pretty well but may be hard to cast to. I've seen guys do well using salmon eggs or worm under a bubble there. I'd try walking all around since it's pretty small. If you guys don't mind a hike I'd walk up to White Pine. You park in the same parking lot and it's a pretty easy hike that takes about an hour and fifteen minutes. You can catch many of the most beautiful brook trout I've ever seen in Utah, some going up to 14 inches.