First carp on the fly

[TylerKunz]

[quote fishned]I guess the point of my post was that an obviously less experienced fisherman asked a legitimate question requesting opinions as to whether his 5 wt was adequate to go after carp. One opinion came back yes. Yours was no. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.

I feel no compulsion to post my fishing resume to legitimize mine. I do feel compelled to say that in my opinion there is no need for anyone (especially a newer fisherman) to cough up a couple hundred bucks when what he already owns is adequate if he uses it right.

I realize you were just trying to be cute. Just wanted to point out that others might take what you have to say seriously.[/quote] this whole thing just sounds hypocritical to me... Indeed everyone is entitled to their opinion, which is what I gave... For some reason you decided to go after me for it. It's ok, I'm a big boy and can handle it. I didn't question your fishing resume like you did mine. It seems I misunderstood your post according to you... Sounds familiar no? As far as a newb using a 5wt, I wouldn't reccomend it. On account of they haven't fought a fish that big (I'm guessing) and may not know how to handle such a strong fish yet. So why risk breaking their brand new rod they got for Christmas when you can buy a cheap 8wt and be safe!
[signature]