Favorite rod holder? Cradle or tube?

[Troutster]

I need a couple of rod holders for the new boat.  It’s a 19 foot aluminum Vexus. I have one old Scotty cradle with the rubber strap.  I see there is a cradle type that has a locking ring.  There are also rocket launcher tube style rod holders.  Plastic, aluminum, solid gold with diamonds…. I’m mounting it on a Cisco track. I’m not much of a troller now but I’ll do what catches fish at the time.  Heading to Powell in October so I may troll there for stripers or walleye.  I don’t have a down rigger at the moment if that matters. The Cisco holders look nice but holy cow they are pricey.  Any suggestions are appreciated.

[BURLEY]

I have these that you are welcome to have. I live in Brigham. I upgraded to steel holders because Kent gave me sturgeon fever years ago. When a300+lb. fish puts a 90* side pull , the composite ones are not enough. Two rods overboard learning curve.
Fish-On =4 holders and 3 mounts. Cabelas' Quickdraw =3 tubes(2 modified) and 2 mounts(similar to Scotty mounts). 









Oh yeah. As the cut away part on the 2 quickdraw tubes shows that I prefer the craddle.

[Bduck]

My boat came with 3 Folbe rod holders, I sold the Scotty holders I use to have. I like the Folbe for the way they open to cradle the rod & close to prevent rod from being yanked out. There is a locking knob to lock cradle down. These are pricey!

Amazon.com: Folbe F080 - Advantage Extended Fishing Rod Holder - Side Mount : Sports & Outdoors

[dubob]

I've used them all on my boat and have settled on the RAM mounts.  Easy to use, has a rod lock function, and is compatible with almost all reel types.  I've never lost a rod/reel or had a RAM holder break.  Solid product with lots of mounting options.