07-08-2011, 10:56 PM
I have caught a lot of cats there but I did it in the toon. I have never caught a quality cat from milner. I am sure there are to be some there some where. Here is the problem. You can drive 1 to 2 hours to get to a place on milner from Buhl. You have about a .5% chance to catch a catfish. You have about .0005% chance to catch a quality catfish.
Or you can drive to any place below swan falls and have a VERY GOOD chance at a cat. You have a GOOD chance at a Quality cat. Even if you go to lake lowell you have a good chance at a cat. The fact is Milner COULD be a quality catfish location IF we imported some fish that are adult breeders from a river or lake that is close to our elevation and climate. Idaho should trade a semi load of trout to Utah for a small truck of breeders from Utah lake or Willard bay. A big load of flatheads from the Mississippi river would work too. Ron
[signature]
Or you can drive to any place below swan falls and have a VERY GOOD chance at a cat. You have a GOOD chance at a Quality cat. Even if you go to lake lowell you have a good chance at a cat. The fact is Milner COULD be a quality catfish location IF we imported some fish that are adult breeders from a river or lake that is close to our elevation and climate. Idaho should trade a semi load of trout to Utah for a small truck of breeders from Utah lake or Willard bay. A big load of flatheads from the Mississippi river would work too. Ron
[signature]